Does major revision mean rejection?

No, major revision does not automatically mean rejection; it's a strong signal that your paper has potential but needs substantial work, representing a "revise and resubmit" opportunity, not a final "reject," though rejection is still possible if revisions aren't satisfactory. It's a common decision in peer review, meaning the editor sees value but requires significant changes, often sending it back to reviewers for re-evaluation after you resubmit.

Can a paper get rejected after a major revision?

Rejection after revision is common and not definitive of your work's value. Most published papers underwent multiple rejections or rounds of revision. Use the episode to strengthen the paper and your revision strategy; the effort invested usually improves clarity and replicability.

What is the acceptance rate for major revisions?

As a very general rule of thumb, first round major revision is 50/50 in terms of eventually being accepted. Getting through the second round with a major revision or better gets you to about an 80% chance of acceptance. Your paper could absolutely still be rejected at this stage.

What happens after major revision?

If major revisions are necessary, additional research, testing, and/or analysis needs to be presented to pass peer-review. If that is the case, once the additional information is added, it gets presented to the editor again essentially as a brand new manuscript, and the process starts over again.

What is considered a major revision?

This means the manuscript needs to be substantially improved before it can be accepted. The acceptance of the manuscript depends on the revisions made.

On Peer Reviewing: "Accepting with Major Revisions" vs. "Reject"

Do major revisions go back to reviewers?

Major revisions are almost always sent back to reviewers for a re-review to determine whether the comments have been addressed and no new comments are raised. If authors are unable to satisfactorily address the comments, further revisions may be required or the paper may be rejected.

What is accept after major revisions?

Accept after major revisions (conditional acceptance): The journal will publish the paper provided the authors make the changes suggested by the reviewers and/or editors.

Is major revision good or bad?

In essence, major revision means you have a lot of work to do. But the good news is that it's a chance to strengthen your paper and improve your chances of publication.

How long does a major revision take?

Usually reviewers are given 3 months to review a manuscript which has been rendered a "major revision" decision.

Is revise and resubmit a rejection?

While this might seem frustrating, it is a good sign. It means that the editor is still invested in your work. Even if it takes several R&Rs, each request for a resubmission makes it more and more likely that your manuscript will finally be accepted.

Is 4.8 a good impact factor?

Yes, a 4.8 impact factor is generally considered very good to excellent, especially as it's well above the typical average (often under 1) and falls into the "good" (around 3) to "very good/excellent" (5+) range for many fields, though its true value depends heavily on the specific academic discipline. It signifies strong visibility and citation rates, but you should always compare it to other journals in the same subject category (quartile/percentile) for the best evaluation. 

What is the easiest medical journal to publish in?

The "easiest" medical journals often balance faster publication, higher acceptance rates (around 60%), and lower barriers, with good options including student-focused ones like the International Journal of Medical Students or Cambridge Medicine Journal, open-access journals with broad scopes like PLOS ONE or MDPI's Journal of Clinical Medicine, and specialized journals with quick turnaround like the International Journal of Nanomedicine. For those with high-quality but simpler studies, MDPI and BioMed Central (BMC) journals offer quicker processes, while journals like Academic Medicine & Surgery focus on speed and accessibility. 

Why would a manuscript be rejected?

Common reasons for rejection

Technical reasons for rejection include: Incomplete data. For example; too small a sample size or missing or poor controls. Poor analysis such as using inappropriate statistical tests or a lack of statistics altogether.

What is the 3 paper rule?

The "3 paper rule" primarily refers to a modern PhD dissertation format where a thesis is structured as three standalone, publishable journal articles connected by an introduction and conclusion, forming a cohesive body of work. It can also refer to general writing/design principles, like the "Rule of Three" for structure (introduction, body, conclusion), the "Rule of Thirds"" in visual design for composition, or a "three-pass reading method"" for deep comprehension. 

Can a university take back a rejection?

It's unlikely that a college will reverse its rejection after an appeal, but admissions experts — and a student who successfully appealed her rejection — offer advice that might help. As college decisions are released, students have joined a trend of responding to rejection letters, rejecting their college rejection.

How to avoid having your manuscript rejected?

How to avoid it:

1. Use precise, academic language and avoid jargon unless clearly defined.
2. Have your manuscript professionally edited or proofread, especially if English is not your first language.
3. Follow the journal's formatting and submission guidelines to the letter.

What are the chances of paper acceptance after major revision?

For journals I have managed, the number of “major revision” papers that are eventually accepted stays solidly between 80-90%. When editors, reviewers, and authors have put time into critiquing and improving a paper, it just seems downright unfair to reject the paper.

What is considered major revision?

Understand what major revisions mean

These might involve improving clarity and cohesiveness, adding more data, revising the methodology or sections and/or revisiting your analysis. Major revisions don't mean your paper is rejected, but it's a chance to refine your work and address reviewers' concerns.

Do papers get rejected after revisions?

It is not uncommon for a journal to request several revisions of an article. Your article may still be rejected after it has been revised although if all suggested revisions have been made, then this is unlikely.

How many revisions before publication?

Ideally, we should aim for no more than three rounds of revisions in total, although there may be exceptions to this, and editors should use their discretion. For transparency, the comments of the reviewers should not be edited or deleted, unless it is to remove offensive language.

Is 2.5 a good impact factor for a journal?

Yes, an impact factor (IF) of 2.5 is generally considered good quality for a journal, placing it above average (most journals have IFs below 2), but not in the elite, top-tier range (which often starts at 5+ or 10+). It signifies decent visibility and citation frequency, but its "goodness" highly depends on the specific academic field, as citation patterns vary significantly between disciplines. 

Why is revision so hard?

The difficulty is not always due to a lack of effort. In many cases, it comes from unclear revision methods, memory challenges, or study habits that do not support long-term learning. Understanding why revision feels difficult is the first step toward improving it.

What is awaiting reviewer scores after major revision?

"Awaiting Reviewer Scores" means that the paper has been assigned the minimum amount of reviewers that the Associate Editor has set for the manuscript. The minimum would be either two or three depending on the publication but the associate editor might have sent a few more invitations around.

Can you pass a PhD with major corrections?

Pass with major corrections

The candidate cannot fail the degree if this outcome is selected, but they will be withdrawn if they fail to complete the corrections to the examiners' satisfaction within the time limit.

Does decision in process mean rejection?

Now, 'Decision in process' means that the AE has made a decision on the manuscript and has communicated this decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who will make the final decision on the manuscript. This may mean a rejection or it may mean a requirement to revise and resubmit.