Is Achilles a top or bottom?

Whether Achilles was a "top" or "bottom" in his relationship with Patroclus is debated, with interpretations varying across ancient sources and modern readings, but Ancient Greek norms often cast the older, dominant partner as "top" (erastes) and the younger, desired one as "bottom" (eromenos), leading to different conclusions, though some philosophers like Plato argued Achilles, being younger/more beautiful, was the "bottom," while others like Aeschylus saw him as the "top," reflecting changing views on their homoerotic bond.

Is the song of Achilles a LGBT book?

Yes, The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller is a prominent LGBTQ+ novel, explicitly portraying the deep, romantic, and lifelong love between the Greek heroes Achilles and Patroclus, a relationship that, while debated in ancient texts, is presented as a central, passionate queer love story in the book, helping many readers understand their own identities.
 

Was Achilles a top or bottom reddit?

Achilles was definitely the bottom.

Was Achilles hidden as a woman?

Based on ancient legend, Achilles' mother, knowing that her son would die if he fought in the Trojan War, disguised him as a woman and entrusted him to King Lycomedes' household, where he lived among the king's daughters.

Which side was Achilles on?

What did Achilles do in the Trojan War? Achilles arrives at Troy with 50 ships. He is the leader of the army known as the Myrmidons and is the best fighter on the side of the Greeks.

Pain When Running? | What Is Achilles Tendonitis & How To Avoid It

Was Achilles a top or a bottom?

Whether Achilles was a "top" or "bottom" in his relationship with Patroclus is debated, with ancient sources like Aeschylus suggesting he was the dominant "top" (erastes) and Plato arguing he was the submissive "bottom" (eromenos) due to his beauty and youth, but the original Homeric texts don't explicitly define their roles, leaving it open to interpretation, though the Greek dynamic often favored the active "top" role for respect.
 

Was there any LGBT in Greek mythology?

Yes, Greek mythology is rich with LGBTQ+ themes, featuring numerous gods, heroes, and figures in same-sex relationships (male and female), gender fluidity, and androgyny, reflecting ancient Greek acceptance of diverse sexualities, though often within specific cultural contexts like pederasty. Key examples include Zeus and Ganymede, Apollo and Hyacinthus, Achilles and Patroclus, Hercules's many male lovers, and the gender-bending Hermaphroditus. 

How common was homosexuality in Greek times?

Second, historical sources for Attica indicate that, although most men may have married, homosexual behavior was widespread among all levels of society and was considered no more opprobrious than heterosexual behavior.

Did Achilles have male lovers?

Aeschylus makes the relationship between Achilles and Patroclus the center of his lost tragedy The Myrmidons (5th century BC), explicitly casting the relationship as homoerotic, pederastic, and sexual.

Whose body did Achilles drag?

This one shows a climactic moment in the Trojan War, when Achilles, roused out of his silence by the killing of his friend Patroclus, kills King Priam's son Hector. Incensed with wrath, Achilles takes his vengeance a step further, and drags Hector's body from his chariot around the walls of Troy.

Was there homosexuality in the Iliad?

The Iliad features the deep bond between Achilles and Patroclus, which many modern scholars interpret as a queer or homoerotic love story, though Homer doesn't explicitly label it as such, leaving room for debate; ancient Greeks like Plato viewed them as lovers, while later figures like Xenophon disagreed, highlighting that interpretations vary, but their profound connection and Achilles' intense grief are central to the epic and open to LGBTQ+ readings. 

Is the Trojan Horse story actually true?

Trojan Horse May Have Elements of True Events

"I like the theory that the 'horse' was based on the notion of a wooden siege engine covered in horse hides," D'Angour says. Many scholars have proposed the Trojan Horse was actually a siege engine of some sort—possibly a battering ram.

Is Achilles a god or demigod?

Achilles is a demigod, the son of a mortal king, Peleus, and the divine sea nymph, Thetis, making him half-mortal and half-divine; he possessed superhuman abilities and was known for his invulnerability, except for his heel, which became his fatal weak spot. He wasn't a god himself, but a hero with divine parentage, a common feature in Greek mythology, like Hercules.
 

Is The Song of Achilles spicy?

The Song of Achilles is considered moderately "spicy" or "steamy," featuring consensual intimate scenes between Achilles and Patroclus, though many readers find it more emotionally charged and romantic with "fade-to-black" moments rather than explicit, graphic content, with some reviewers rating it a 3/5 on steam, meaning some scenes are present but not overly dominant or detailed. While not as explicit as some New Adult (NA) romance, it definitely contains sensuality and mature themes, including discussions of sexual violence and trauma.
 

Did Achilles and Patroclus ever kiss?

Many Greco-Roman authors read their relationship as a romantic one—it was a common and accepted interpretation in the ancient world. We even have a fragment from a lost tragedy of Aeschylus, where Achilles speaks of his and Patroclus' “frequent kisses.”

Why is The Song of Achilles controversial?

The Song of Achilles controversy centers on {Madeline Miller}'s portrayal of Achilles and Patroclus as gay lovers, a reading supported by some ancient sources (Plato) but contested by others (Xenophon) and conflicting with later interpretations (Brad Pitt's Troy), sparking debates about queer representation, "straightwashing" of history, and whether the novel imposes modern monogamous values onto the complex ancient world. Critics also debate its focus on their youth and relationship over the Iliad's themes, treatment of female characters, and potential simplification of historical ambiguity, though many praise it as a poignant, accessible retelling.
 

Who slept with Achilles?

In addition to his close relationship with Patroclus, Achilles had Briseis. In various retellings, she is a slave, a concubine, or a wife. Agamemnon takes Briseis from Achilles, which causes Achilles to leave the war. He only returns after the death of Patroclus and when Briseis is returned to him.

Is Patroclus a girl or boy?

Patroclus acted as a male role model for Achilles, being both kinder than him as well as wiser regarding counsel. Patroclus's early life, including his flight to the house of Peleus, is narrated later in the Iliad, when his ghost appears to Achilles reminding him about his past and giving him advice about his burial.

Can a straight man read the song of Achilles?

Instead, the entire narrative focuses on the external--how attractive Achilles is, and the external consequences for their relationship (such as the disapproval of Achilles' mother). This is what really convinced me that this book was written for straight readers.

Which country has the highest LGBT population?

It's hard to pinpoint one country with the absolute most LGBTQ+ people due to privacy, but Brazil often ranks highest in percentage of population identifying as LGBTQ+ (around 14-15%), followed by countries like Spain, the U.S., Canada, and Sweden, while countries with massive populations like India and China likely have very large total numbers, even if their percentage is lower, though data is less consistent.
 

What did the Spartans think of homosexuality?

The Greeks did not conceive of sexual orientation in our terms (e.g., as straight or gay): Later in life, men would be expected to marry women and to raise families. In Athens and Sparta, homosexuality was practiced to various degrees, and its status was somewhat “complicated,” according to Plato's Pausanias.

When did homosexuality begin?

2450 BCE: The first documentation of a same-sex couple was recorded in Egypt when Khnumhotep and Niankhkhnum were buried together in a tomb with paintings that depicted them embracing and kissing. 27 BCE: During the Roman Empire, same-sex marriage was common and largely accepted.

How does god view LGBTQ?

As New Testament Scholar Daniel Kirk has pointed out, Christians today would do well by the tradition of the apostles and our current witness in the world to recognize that theological abstractions aside, God has already clearly embraced LGBTQ+ people into full communion, and it is now the church's responsibility to ...

Was Artemis queer?

Artemis's identity is ambiguous but many other god's queerness is very explicit. Despite this, it's Artemis who is famous as “the gay one” to the general public. People are generally unaware that it was common for male gods to have male lovers.

Was Aphrodite LGBTQ?

Aphrodite and her attendants were also associated with what we now call LGBTQ+ identities. She was believed to encourage male homosexuality, and we have already discussed depictions of Aphrodite as an intersex figure. The Greeks at times even worshipped intersex individuals.