What is the desk reject rate for Nature?

Nature has a very high desk reject rate, typically around 80-85%, meaning most submissions are rejected by editors without being sent for peer review due to rigorous selectivity and high impact factors, with only about 7-8% of all submissions ultimately accepted for publication, according to reports and data from Nature-branded journals.

What is the rejection rate for Nature?

Nature's rejection rate is extremely high, with only about 7-8% of submitted manuscripts accepted, meaning a rejection rate of roughly 92-93% for the main journal, as most papers (around 80%) are rejected outright before even peer review. The overall selectivity is very stringent, requiring significant novelty and broad impact, with acceptance rates varying across the broader Nature Portfolio journals. 

What percent of papers get desk rejected?

This resulted in an overall acceptance rate of 13%. Hence, in the case of TRD, desk rejection makes up 81.6% of all rejections. In our dataset, a similar proportion of 83.6% of papers that entered the transfer system were desk rejected, matching the case of TRD and many other journals based on our knowledge.

What is the rejection rate for science advances desk?

The editorial process is selective enough that, according to How to Publish Your Article in Science Advances in 8 Steps, 80% of submissions to Science Advances are rejected. That same 2023 guide also notes that the average time from submission to publication is 6 months.

What is the acceptance rate for Nature comms?

Acceptance rate of Nat. Commun. is ~14% compared to about 29% of the PRL. No wonder, Nat. Commun. is able to maintain a high impact factor of about 16.5, compared to about 9 of PRL.

5 reasons why 80% of research papers get rejected without a review | What to do instead?

Is 2.7 a good impact factor?

You can find a journal's impact factor by referring to the Journal Citations Report (JCR) or Scopus. 🍋 What is an average 'good' impact factor? In general, an impact factor of 10 or higher is considered remarkable, while 3 is good, and the average score is less than 1.

Is getting published in Nature a big deal?

Yes, publishing in Nature (or Science and Cell) is a very big deal in academia, signaling high-impact research that significantly boosts a researcher's career, leading to promotions, grants, and prestigious job offers due to its high prestige, wide reach, and influence, though the process can be competitive and lengthy. 

Is desk rejection bad?

It offers a quicker decision, prevents long delays, and can even open up new possibilities for your manuscript. By recognising that rejection is often more about fit than quality, you can take a desk rejection in stride and use it as a springboard for improving your work and finding the right journal for your research.

Is 2.5 a good impact factor?

An impact factor of 2.5 means that, on average, the articles published one or two years ago have been cited two and a half times.” The impact factor has risen to an elevated status. Many believe that the higher the impact factor, the higher the quality of the journal.

How long does a desk rejection take?

Desk rejection: this will usually come within a week or so of submitting your article. A desk rejection is where a member of the editorial team has 'prescreened' your manuscript, considering if it should be sent out to review or not.

How to avoid a desk reject?

They suggest several writing touchpoints that can help you avoid a desk reject, including... 1. Effective Communication 2. Tell a story 3. Write a clear introduction that tells the what (the problem), so what (why the problem is important), and now what (future research) 4.

What is the 3 paper rule?

The "3-paper rule" primarily refers to a doctoral dissertation structure where the thesis is composed of three separate, publishable journal articles, linked by an introduction and conclusion, instead of a traditional single, long manuscript. It also relates to principles in scientific writing, suggesting structuring parts (like introductions or paragraphs) into three key points for clarity, or a method for efficiently reading papers in three passes. 

What author was rejected 23 times?

The author famously rejected 23 times was Frank Herbert for his science fiction classic Dune, which was turned down by 23 publishers before being accepted by a small press, eventually becoming a massive bestseller and cultural phenomenon.
 

How prestigious is a Nature publication?

According to Science, another academic journal, being published in Nature has been known to carry a certain level of prestige in academia. In particular, empirical papers are often highly cited, which can lead to promotions, grant funding, and attention from the mainstream media.

What is the controversy with the Nature journal?

Nature journal accused of abandoning science for social justice. A leading scientific journal has defended its efforts to boost the diversity of researchers cited in its pages after an academic accused it of abandoning science to pursue a “social justice agenda”.

How hard is it to get a publication in Nature?

Only about 8% of submitted manuscripts are accepted for publication in Nature making it an incredibly competitive endeavour. Furthermore, 'breaking into' these top-tier journals is more difficult if you haven't previously published with them.

Is Springer Nature a good journal?

We have an 86% excellent/ good rating from authors and are ranked no. 1 in terms of reputation, compared to our competitors.

Can an impact factor be manipulated?

However, impact factors may be manipulated by editors. According to the ex- planatory statements and announcements made by the authors submitting their work to the journals, the impact factor is still being di- rectly manipulated [4–6].

What is a "predatory" journal?

Predatory journals—also called fraudulent, deceptive, or pseudo-journals—are publications that claim to be legitimate scholarly journals, but misrepresent their publishing practices.

What to do after desk rejection?

You could also write an appeal letter to the journal editor. Or you may want to return to your lab, office or the field and collect more data. To decide on a publishing strategy after desk rejection, it's important to understand the reasons behind the manuscript rejection.

Is 2.5 a good impact factor for a journal?

Yes, a 2.5 impact factor (IF) is generally considered good or decent, falling into the respectable range for many fields, though it's not "top-tier" like journals with IFs of 10+; it signifies that articles in that journal are cited reasonably often, but its actual quality depends heavily on the specific research discipline, as averages vary significantly.
 

What is a typical reason for desk rejection?

1. Submitting a topic that is outside the scope of the journal. Submitting such a paper typically represents a lack of preparation on the part of the author. Unsurprisingly, it receives a desk rejection decision.

Is Nature or Cell more prestigious?

Each of these journals represents a different category with Cell being the top of its field, Nature Cell Biology a bit below, and Molecular Biology of the Cell well regarded for its solid work.

What is the acceptance rate for Nature publication?

Who decides which papers to publish? Nature's aim is to publish the best research across a wide range of scientific fields, which means it has to be highly selective. As a result, only about 8% of submitted manuscripts will be accepted for publication.

Which is better, Nature or Elsevier?

Key context: Elsevier manages over 2,700+ journals and owns platforms like Scopus and ScienceDirect, while Springer (Springer Nature) publishes around 3,000+ journals and operates SpringerOpen for fully open-access publishing. Both are COPE members and follow strict publication ethics.