What's the difference between Montessori and Charlotte Mason?

The Montessori teacher guides the child as the child chooses what they learn. The Charlotte Mason teacher presents the carefully selected texts and then directs the child to pay attention to and engage with various ideas relationally.

What did Charlotte Mason say about Montessori?

While Mason appreciated Montessori's environment and publicly lauded the students, she also felt they were allowed too much freedom and weren't given enough discipline. She was also opposed to Montessori's exercises with the senses.

What is Charlotte Mason teaching style?

The Charlotte Mason homeschool method is an educational philosophy that emphasizes providing a rich, liberal education while using methods that engage a child's natural curiosity and enthusiasm. This approach also places an emphasis on creating an environment in which children feel safe, secure, and respected.

Why not to choose Montessori?

1. Lack of structure: Montessori education is known for its emphasis on child-led learning and independence, which can sometimes result in a lack of structure. Some children may struggle with the freedom and flexibility of this approach and may require more structure and guidance to thrive.

What type of child is Montessori good for?

Montessori is “right” for families with a range of communication styles and learning expectations; however, families who are generally disorganized (arrive late in the morning, pick up children at varying times, and have difficulty reading and responding to school correspondence with consistency), may experience ...

The difference : Charlotte Mason & Montessori method of learning

What is the downside of Montessori?

The Montessori method has some drawbacks including the lack of consistent quality implementation, difficulty in transitioning to higher education, and high tuition.

Do kids in Montessori do better?

The academic and nonacademic effects were strongest for young children, with the greatest gains seen in kindergartners and 1st graders. Researchers found that when compared to traditional educational programs, Montessori programs at both private and public schools yielded higher academic and nonacademic gains.

What is the biggest criticism of Montessori?

Are kids happier in Montessori schools?

The findings, published in academic journal Frontiers in Psychology, suggest a Montessori education is superior to conventional education in terms of long-term psychological well-being outcomes or what the researchers describe as “the felt experience of health, happiness and flourishing”.

Is Montessori good for ADHD?

One of the other key benefits of Montessori for ADHD is that it allows children to learn at their own pace. Often, children with ADHD thrive when they are able to focus their education on one thing or one concept at a time.

Why choose Charlotte Mason?

Benefits of a Charlotte Mason Education

Keeping students engaged with their learning by keeping lessons short and manageable. Instilling a love for literature through the use of living books. Teaching a child to express him/herself clearly and articulately through narration practice.

Does Charlotte Mason have a curriculum?

Our curriculum is designed to help you homeschool the Charlotte Mason way with confidence and freedom! Your whole family is combined together for as many subjects as possible as you enjoy a wonderful mix of modern and classic books.

What does Charlotte Mason homeschool look like?

A Charlotte Mason Homeschool schedule should include short lessons, afternoon free time, nature walks and read aloud time. We had formal structured lessons four days per week in the elementary years. The other day was left for errands, field trips, visiting and special events.

Why does Montessori discourage praise?

Unearned and Unnecessary Praise

The adult becomes the judge, and motivation becomes external rather than internal. This "conditional parenting" teaches children to behave in a certain way in order to be loved. It becomes another method of control, just like punishment.

Why did Maria Montessori give up her son?

Maria did not raise her son. Because Mario was born out of wedlock, he was taken in as a baby and raised by some of Maria's family members who lived in the country. This was to avoid scandal.

Why are Montessori schools so quiet?

Silence reigns at Montessori schools by design. The Montessori approach is child-centered — encouraging children to be independent and learn at their own pace. Montessori views children's play as work and respects their independence and natural curiosity.

Are Montessori children successful later in life?

Questions. Are Montessori Children successful later in life? Research studies show that Montessori children are well prepared academically, socially and emotionally for later in life.

What is the best age to send to Montessori?

The best age to enroll your child in a Montessori school is around 3 years old when they are most sensitive to their surroundings. During this time, children learn a variety of skills while pursuing their interests. So, look for a Montessori school as soon as you can.

Why Montessori is better than daycare?

Traditional daycares usually rely on instructor-directed discipline to function, but in Montessori education, children are free to move around the classroom, exploring and learning through a variety of activities. This freedom allows children to learn through interaction in their stimulating environment.

Who disagrees with Montessori?

The American philosopher and educator John Dewey, and his student William Heard Kirpatrick, thought Montessori's program stifled creativity and focused too much on the individual. Kirpatrick went on a campaign against the Montessori method in the 1920s, attacking it in a popular pamphlet.

How does Montessori teach math?

Montessori teachers believe that children learn math concepts more easily when they are presented in a concrete, hands-on way, rather than through abstract instruction. This means that children use manipulatives, such as beads, blocks, and cubes, to understand math concepts before they move to more abstract concepts.

Does Montessori work for autism?

As with autism, children with AS respond well to the predictable routines, social graces and manners of speech practised in a well-organised Montessori classroom. Montessori teachers model sensitive behaviours, value diversity and respect the right of all children, including those with AS to 'be themselves'.

What age does Montessori stop?

Currently, most Montessori programs begin at the Early Childhood level (for children ages 2.5 – 6 years). However there are also programs for infants and toddlers (birth – age 3), Elementary-aged children (ages 6 – 12), and Secondary students (ages 12 – 18).

Do Montessori schools give homework?

Many authentic Montessori schools do not assign homework until upper elementary or middle school- and even then it is more individualized rather than rote style.

When to stop Montessori?

Montessori concludes when children reach the age of 12, aligning with their school and individual capabilities. This education program can lay a foundation for early learning in children.